RELATED: Dungeons And Dragons: The Case For And Against Releasing 6e
Thus, is why one must consider every edition that Dungeons & Dragons has ever produced. Doing so allows one to determine which variation of this esteemed TTRPGsuits them best. Many may find solace in Dungeons & Dragons 5e, while others value the original above all else. Regardless, it is fascinating to see how the world’s greatest roleplaying game has changed over the years.
8 Dungeons & Dragons - Original Edition (1974)
Pros:
Simple structure Customizable rules Combat-focused Provides an interesting/nostalgic experience
Cons:
Lacks cohesive structure Underdeveloped rules Inadequate exploration and social interaction support Lends itself to wargamers Few character options Its age shows
The original Dungeons & Dragons - colloquially known as the original edition - is a far cry from later installments. Instead, it was a fantasy-inspired wargame, a strategy-based experience touching upon themes of warfare. As such, Dungeons & Dragons Original Edition put much emphasis on combat and tactical thought. While it is much different than other versions, it lends itself well to particular tastes.
Dungeons & Dragons Original Edition is perfect for longtime fans of the franchise and wargamers. Despite its simplicity and lack of cohesion, it evokes powerful feelings of nostalgia. Moreover, Dungeons & Dragons Original Edition’s laxity allows experienced fans to customize it to their liking. Those that enjoy combat will also take to this version quickly. Otherwise, Dungeons & Dragons Original Edition is likely not the best choice.
7 Dungeons & Dragons - Basic Edition (1977)
Pros:
Beginner-friendly Cohesive structure Simple rules Establishes itself as a roleplaying game Lends itself to all adventuring pillars of D&D Provides a basic yet enjoyable experience
Cons:
Too simplistic Offers little content Its age shows
Dungeons & Dragons Basic Edition is the beginner-friendly counterpart of 1st and 2nd Edition. It forewent the complicated rules and unforgiving nature of the Advanced Edition. Therefore, Dungeons & Dragons Basic Edition was able to introduce new players seamlessly and retain them. Its simplistic features allow for easy and overall enjoyable play.
RELATED: Dungeons & Dragons: Subclasses From Previous Editions That 5e Should Have
Dungeons & Dragons Basic Edition provides much leeway to an assortment of players. It supports every adventuring pillar of Dungeons & Dragons and is remarkably easy to understand. While its fundamental aspects seem dull at times, Dungeons & Dragons Basic Edition provides a well-rounded experience. Thus, making it a perfect choice for most fans of the franchise, both old and new.
6 Advanced Dungeons & Dragons - 1st Edition (1977)
Pros:
Introduces popular staples of D&D Cohesive structure Advanced rules Easy implementation of house rules Combat-focused Provides a complex and challenging experience
Cons:
Steep learning curve Inadequate exploration and social interaction support Lends itself to wargamers Complicated and unforgiving combat
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st Edition introduces many staples of the franchise. It is the more complex counterpart to Basic Edition, thus making it a game for experienced fans. So, while it offered little aid to newcomers, Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st Edition was a thrilling experience. Its challenging and well-developed playstyle lends itself well to combat-oriented and - or - seasoned players.
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st Edition offers battle-heavy play and immense difficulty. As such, it is not for those who value exploration and social interaction. Moreover, Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 1st Edition does not bode well for the faint-hearted. Therefore, only those that value grueling encounters and seemingly insurmountable challenges will enjoy this version.
5 Advanced Dungeons & Dragons - 2nd Edition (1989)
Pros:
Introduces popular staples of D&D Beginner-Friendly Cohesive structure Advanced rules Greater emphasis on all adventuring pillars of D&D Variety of character options Provides a challenging and enjoyable experience
Cons:
Unforgiving combat Restrictive limitations and requirements
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 2nd Edition shares many similarities to its predecessor, although with significant improvements. It still emphasizes combat and difficulty above all else except with support for other adventuring pillars. Thus, making Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 2nd Edition a more well-rounded and inclusive version. Even so, it continues leaning towards combat-focused and - or - hardened fans.
RELATED: Table-Top RPGs You Didn’t Know Were Coming In 2021 & 2022
Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 2nd Edition lends itself to an assortment of players but chiefly combat, nonetheless. Therefore, requiring participants to exercise a keen understanding of the various dangers and foes one could face in battle. With more options and leeway for combat alternatives, however, there is less of a need. So, Advanced Dungeons & Dragons 2nd Edition is an excellent choice for most players.
4 Dungeons & Dragons - 3rd Edition (2000)
Pros:
Introduces the d20 system Introduces a developed skill system Cohesive structure Simplified rules Variety of character options Unrestricted character customization Provides a well-rounded and enjoyable experience
Cons:
Balance issues Ruling issues Unforgiving spells Unimpactful leveling Essentially, a worse version of the 3. 5 edition
Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition is largely overshadowed by other versions, as it lacks any enticing features. It introduces the renowned d20 system and implements many notable elements of the franchise. Even so, Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition possesses a variety of glaring issues resolved in 3.5 Edition. Regardless, it offers a more than enjoyable experience.
Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition presents a variety and customization unseen in the franchise before. Thus, allowing players to become more creative and thoughtful of their characters. Moreover, every adventuring pillar holds equivalent influence, granting a well-rounded experience. In the end, however, there is little reason for players to choose Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition above all else.
3 Dungeons & Dragons - 3.5 Edition (2003)
Pros:
Revised or reworked many issues of the 3rd edition Cohesive structure Simplified rules Variety of character options Unrestricted character customization Provides a great deal of content Provides a well-rounded and enjoyable experience
Cons:
Ruling issues Unforgiving spells Unimpactful leveling
Dungeons & Dragons 3.5 Edition is essentially a widescale overhaul of 3rd Edition. Many overt faults, inconsistencies, and inequities were revised to create an overall balanced experience. Thus, is why many regard Dungeons & Dragons 3.5 Edition to be perfect. While that opinion is purely subjective, this version does provide a near-flawless and enjoyable style of play.
RELATED: The Best Tabletop RPG Video Game Adaptations
Dungeons & Dragons 3.5 Editions offers an optimal experience to a wide variety of players. In addition to its numerous improvements, this version possesses a vast amount of content. There are dozens of books offering so much more to the already impressive base game. Therefore, Dungeons & Dragons 3.5 Edition provides a great deal that almost every player can enjoy.
2 Dungeons & Dragons - 4th Edition (2008)
Pros:
Cohesive structure Advanced rules Combat-focused Customizable Well-balanced character options Provides a tactical and challenging experience
Cons:
Unforgiving combat Inadequate exploration and social interaction support More akin to MMO video games than a roleplaying game Lacks many popular qualities of D&D
Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition is a stark differentiation from its largely successful predecessor. Rather than continuing the formula of previous installments, it appeals to a different fanbase, hardcore MMO players. As such, Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition reverts to something more akin to the 1st and Original Editions. Thus, it lends itself well to those who favor combat and difficulty above all else.
Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition supports this style of play in a masterful and well-balanced manner. There are no disparities involving rules or character balance. So, there was little confusion and feeling of inadequacy in one’s character, unlike other versions. Despite this, Dungeons & Dragons 4th Edition only works to garner battle-oriented players and fans of MMOs.
1 Dungeons & Dragons - 5th Edition (2014)
Pros:
Beginner-friendly Cohesive structure Simple rules Allows for much customization and improvising Quick and easy character creation Variety of character options Most modern edition of D&D Provides a well-rounded, simple, and enjoyable experience
Cons:
Balance issues Customization and improvising can cause issues
Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition is the latest version of the franchise. As such, there are immediate benefits such as better support, significant popularity, and new content. Alone, Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition is likely the most streamlined and mainstream version of all time. It offers a diverse and tailorable experience far better than any other edition.
Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition allows players and Dungeon Masters alike to bend the rules to their whims. While this ability requires discipline, it can make for remarkably thrilling and dynamic moments. Moreover, one may alter Dungeons & Dragons 5th Edition to better suit their particular styles of play. Thus, making this version among the most versatile and acceptable of the franchise.
MORE: Table-Top RPGs: Things A Good DM Needs (Besides Dice)
